Skip to main content

Why South Africans are being misled by the recycling numbers on packaging

| Going green

Turns out, recycling symbols on South African packaging mean very little. Despite being marked with recycling branding, a depressing amount of plastic cannot be recycled in South Africa.

Woolworths and Checkers are moving towards a new labelling system which is more honest about whether packaging can be recycled.

South Africans can be forgiven for assuming that packaging marked with a number in a triangle can be recycled.

This is wrong.

In fact, a depressing amount of packaging cannot yet be recycled in South Africa.

The number 1 to 7, usually printed within a triangle, refers to the type of resin contained in the packaging. 

 

Because this looks so similar to the recycle symbol, it's a common misinterpretation that the packaging can be recycled in South Africa.

But while most resin types are technically recyclable, many are not recyclable in South Africa. The original numbered labels were designed to assist waste collectors and waste separators, and not the customer.

 

Jay Caboz
Woolworths recycle label vs Pick n Pay.
 

Here's how different retailers are approaching this conundrum:

Woolworths

Woolworths has been changing the wording on its packaging to reflect a more honest indication of what can be recycled in South Africa. If a product is marked with "widely recycled in SA", Woolworths clients should be assured that it is recyclable.

“If there isn’t an existing industry [in SA] collecting and recycling certain types of plastics, then the plastic type in question will be considered as ‘not currently recycled’ even if it is technically possible to do so,” a Woolworths spokesperson told Business Insider South Africa. 

Woolworths have made a commitment that by 2022 all packaging will either be recyclable or reusable.

Visiting the local Woolworths we found a few execptions. Take for instance these Woolworths blueberries labelled with a PET 1.  

 

Woolworth's blueberries. Photo Jay Caboz
 

The majority of the goods in the store were labeled correctly, but sadly a large amount is not recycled in South Africa. 

 

Jay Caboz
Recycle lables
 
Jay Caboz
Woolworths avos.
 
Jay Caboz
Woolworths salad.
 
Jay Caboz
Woolworths pre-packaged meals.
 

 


Shoprite and Checkers

These stores are also adopting more straight-forward wording on its own packaging. Products marked "plastic recycled currently" can be safely recycled.

We had a look at some of the products in Shoprite and Checkers stores and noticed that, for example, some of the pre-packaged meals were marked with this wording, and others not.   

 

Chicken Caesar pasta salad
 
Checkers
 
Checkers
(left) Red berry fruit salad and (right) blueberries
 

We also found that Shoprite introduced fully biodegradable and compostable avo punnets, which can biodegrade by 90% within three to six months of composting.

 

Jay Caboz
Biodegradable and compostable avo punnets
 

The group says from November 2018, the packaging of various other fruit and vegetable packs are being replaced with fully biodegradable and compostable containers, which will reduce their use of foam punnets by 3.5 million punnets a year.


Pick n Pay 

Pick n Pay is slow off the mark, and its packaging is still mostly marked with the resin codes. 

 

Jay Caboz
Pick n Pay pre-packaged meal.
Jay Caboz

According to Andre Nel, GM for Sustainability at Pick n Pay, most of their private label packaging (except for very small labels) still includes resin identification codes. 

“We are currently reviewing our labelling to include clear on-pack information about the recyclability of packaging to make it easier for customers to understand,” said Nel.

While they have not transitioned to more honest labels, Pick n Pay say it’s safe to recycle a “high percentage” of their own branded goods including their juices; carbonated soft drinks; oil and other products in PET bottles and jars; punnets used for fresh products; bottles for household cleaning; and sleeves on convenience meals.

“Even though some of these codes aren’t yet recycled in South Africa, we believe it is important that all plastic types that are technically recyclable remain in the recycling stream.”

We found a few items that were labelled as 'suitable for recycling' - on milk cartons and avo punnets. 

 

Pick n Pay milk
 
Jay Caboz
Pick n Pay avo.
 

But, this 'suitable for recycling' does not mean it is recycled in South Africa, it simply means it is recyclable. If you buy the avos from Woolworths you'll see a different story.

 

Pick n Pay avo.
 
Jay Caboz
Woolworths avos.
 

 


 

 

The state of recycling in South Africa

According to the Department of Environmental Affairs’ (DEA) State of the Waste report, South Africa generated 54.2 million tonnes of general waste in 2017.

An estimated 38.6% of the waste was recycled - up from only 10% in 2012. But the DEA found that with the correct infrastructure, millions of tons more could be recycled. 

Pin It

Related Articles

Woolworths pilots the removal of plastic barrie...

In support of the 2024 Earth Day theme “Planet vs Plastic”, Woolworths announced a 12-store trial to remove plastic barrier bags from its stores.

World Water Day: Shoprite donates bottled water...

Shoprite donates 7000 litres of bottled water to various Early Childhood Development education centres in the Verulam area.

Shoprite Group leads SA retailers in addressing...

By: Staff Reporter – IOL Business The Shoprite Group said it has cemented its position as South Africa’s top-rated retailer for corporate disclosure, transparency and performance on climate change and water security.

Pick n Pay incentives recycling by adding more ...

Pick n Pay takes another stride towards environmental sustainability by introducing a further ten more Reverse Vending Machines (RVMs) in stores across Gauteng, Eastern, and Western Cape, which will soon be integrated...

SPAR makes progress in advancing sustainable pa...

The SPAR Group has announced a series of initiatives aimed at curbing the environmental impact of plastic packaging materials.  This commitment aligns with the Group’s dedication to phasing out harmful plastics and will contribute significantly t...