Skip to main content

Masstores' Game wins ConCourt battle against Pick n Pay

| Legislation

Walmart-owned Masstores has succeeded in its appeal at the Constitutional Court to have the right to operate as a supermarket that sells fresh foods at a Western Cape shopping centre.

The dispute centred on whether Pick n Pay can use an exclusive right to trade at the Cape Gate shopping centre to prevent Game from selling fresh foods at the complex.

Pick n Pay said that Game’s selling of fresh foods interfered with its contractual agreement to have the exclusive right to trade as a supermarket in the shopping centre, which is owned by Hyprop.

The court on Friday, though, ruled that Masstores did not violate any agreements by trading as a supermarket.

Justice Johan Froneman, who read out the judgement, explained that instead of making the case against the lessors Hyprop, Pick n Pay made the case against the tenant Masstores.

However, there was no "contractual relationship" between the two retailers. 

Pick n Pay contended Masstores' breach with its own lease agreement, as far back as 2006, which prohibited it from operating as a general food supermarket in the shopping complex. Pick n Pay argued that it was an "intentional interference" with its contractual relations with Hyprop. 

Pick n Pay had obtained an interdict from the High Court to prevent Masstores from operating as a supermarket at the shopping centre. The Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) upheld the finding that Masstores breached its own lease agreement. 

However, in the majority judgment by nine judges, with the exception of one, the leave to appeal was granted.

"Masstores's trading as a general supermarket does not deprive Pick n Pay of its entitelement to continue trading as a general supermarket in the shopping centre," stated Froneman.

He added that Pick n Pay's "exclusivity" may have been impacted, but this exclusivity was not "usurped" by Masstores. 

The appeal was further succeeded with costs, to be paid by the respondents Pick n Pay.

Click here to Read the full judgement:

 

Pin It

Related Articles

NHI: Business gears up for possible legal battl...

By: Ahmed Areff - News24 Business Unity SA (BUSA) has confirmed that it will consider legal action after President Cyril Ramaphosa signs the controversial National Health Insurance Bill into law this week. 

Electricity Regulation Bill will open competiti...

By: Siyabonga Mkhwanazi - IOL Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe says the Electricity Regulation Amendment Bill will open competition in the market.

New Minimum Wage Set to Take Effect on March 1s...

As the countdown to the implementation of the new minimum wage draws closer, the nation finds itself at the precipice of a profound transformation in its labour landscape. With revised minimum wage regulations set to come into force on March 1st...

Spar director fined R1 million after refusing n...

By: Brenda Masilela - IOL The Johannesburg Labour Court has fined Spar director R1 million after he refused on more than one occasion to reinstate a worker who was unfairly dismissed.

SARS wants to change VAT collection in South Af...

The South African Revenue Service (SARS) has published a discussion paper on ways to modernise the VAT collection process.