Skip to main content

The one way BEE is doing more harm than good

| Research tools

Only 28% of senior management roles in South Africa are held by women according to a new report by accounting and advisory firm, Grant Thornton.

While higher than that of last year, the percentage of women business leaders has not changed significantly since the start of Grant Thornton’s research 13 years ago, when this figure was at 26%, the firm said.

“We have made no progress, and the small change is probably only due to sampling variations,” said Lee-Anne Bac, director: Advisory Services at Grant Thornton Johannesburg.

“Unfortunately, we have a very patriarchal culture in Africa, including South Africa. Until we make a concerted effort to change our mindset to the role of women in the workplace, at home and society at large we’re going to continue to battle with inequality in the workplace. Change starts with how we treat children – we should be striving to raise boys and girls equally in a gender neutral environment.”

The annual report, Women in business: New perspectives on risk and reward, is based on Grant Thornton’s International Business Report which surveys 5,500 businesses in 36 economies, also shows that almost a third (31%) of SA companies have no women at all in senior management positions.

Globally, too, the pace of change towards gender equity remains glacial. South Africa is slightly ahead of the global average of 25% of senior roles held by women (SA: 28%) and better than the global average of 34% of businesses with no women in senior management (SA: 31%).

“We shouldn’t, however, be comparing ourselves against the global situation,” Bac said. “Instead, we should strive to match those countries that are performing at above average rates.”

The MINT economies (Mexico, Indonesia, Nigeria and Turkey) saw the biggest improvements, with the proportion of senior roles held by women rising from 24% in 2016 to 28% in 2017 and the percentage of businesses with no women in senior management falling from 36% in 2016 to 27% in 2017.

This is in significant contrast to the major developed economies of the G7, which have remained static compared to 2016 with 22% of senior roles held by women and 39% of businesses with no women in senior management.

Common senior roles for women

The report reveals it is still most common for senior women to be in supporting roles, particularly as human resources directors or chief financial officers. However, there has been a slow rise in the number of women in chief executive officer roles in South Africa, from 7% in 2015 to 9% in 2016 and 10% in 2017.

“Again, however, the rise is not very significant,” said Bac, who believes we have reached a point of complacency in this country. “Businesses have put some women in management positions, ticked that box, and now they are not doing anything further.

“Instead, companies should constantly be working to improve gender diversity in the workplace. We have too few women in management positions, and until we tilt that balance it will remain difficult for women to influence the change. Women are fighting from a position of lack of power.”

B-BBEE targets work against gender diversity

Pushing the importance of gender diversity further down the list of priorities are the number of other pressing issues currently facing South Africa. Companies are focused on B-BBEE targets, which are legislated, rather than on diversity targets, which are not.

“In addition, the latest Women in Business IBR survey showed some men are resisting competition from women,” said Bac.  “Both are competing for the same senior positions, and it is far easier for men if they only have to compete with 50% of the population.

“But it’s the fault of women as well,” she noted. “We’re not fighting back.”

Focus shifting away from gender equality

The worrying sense that the issue of gender diversity is beginning to lose its bite was also noted in this year’s Grant Thornton Women in Business IBR report.

“We simply cannot let this happen while progress is still marginal,” said Global leader for tax services and sponsor of women in leadership at Grant Thornton, Francesca Lagerberg.

“Companies today need to be more productive, more innovative and in many ways more open if they are to thrive.”

The report looked at the issue of risk and reward, finding that men and women see risk and opportunity in different ways, and that they act differently as a result.

Related Articles

Checkers killing Pick n Pay in home delivery

Daily Investor Pick n Pay CEO Sean Summers said they started home delivery two decades ago but that Checkers took the lead through their Sixty60 service.

How much money cashiers, trolley collectors, an...

Employment and Labour Minister Thulas Nxesi gazetted the new sectoral determinations for workers in South Africa’s wholesale and retail sectors in the first quarter of the year, which reveals the minimum baseline wage for workers in the sector for...

Woolworths bosses score massive R255 million pa...

Woolworths released its annual remuneration report for 2023 – revealing how much the retailer’s top execs earned over the last financial year.

Cheapest retailer for a full basket of grocerie...

A recent consumer report compared the prices of 23 grocery items across four of South Africa’s most popular food retailers – revealing Shoprite as the cheapest option.

Pick n Pay smart shoppers ‘sit on’ R250 million...

Cash-strapped consumers might unknowingly have extra cash in their wallets. Pick n Pay has reported that over 11 million customers have unclaimed Smart Shopper points already loaded on their card, totalling over R250 million in cash-back rewards.